What if we can't agree on a parenting plan?
Please note that these answers are not legal advice. If you’re in need of legal advice or a lawyer please visit our Expert Guide
If you and your ex can’t agree on a parenting plan, there are structured steps to follow to reach a resolution:
Mediation (First Step)
Most states require mediation if parents can’t agree.
A neutral third-party mediator helps you negotiate a plan that works for both sides.
Mediation is confidential, less expensive than court, and often quicker.
If you reach an agreement, it’s submitted to the court for approval.
Court Intervention (If Mediation Fails)
If mediation is unsuccessful, you’ll need to go to family court where a judge will decide:
Custody arrangements: Who gets physical and legal custody.
Visitation schedules: How time is divided, including holidays and vacations.
Decision-making responsibilities: How major decisions (school, health, religion) are handled.
The judge’s main consideration is the best interests of the child, which includes:
Stability and routine for the child
Emotional and physical safety
Educational continuity
Relationship with both parents
Willingness of each parent to cooperate
Court-Ordered Parenting Plan
The judge may order a standard parenting plan if you can’t agree.
This is often less flexible and tailored than if you had agreed privately.
The court’s decision is legally binding, and violating it can lead to legal consequences.
Child Custody Evaluation (In Complex Cases)
In some high-conflict cases, the court may order a custody evaluation.
A trained professional (like a psychologist or social worker) assesses both parents and the child to make recommendations.
This includes interviews, home visits, and reviewing the child’s needs and family dynamics.
Modifications Can Be Made Later
If the court orders a plan, you can request modifications later if circumstances change (e.g., relocation, job change, health issues).
Example Scenario:
If you want your child to go to a specific school and your ex disagrees, mediation would be the first step. If that fails, a judge would look at factors like proximity, the child’s current routine, and each parent's involvement to decide.
Get more info with The Divorce Guide →
Looking for more guidance and/or got more questions? Find the support you need with out Expert Guide!