Jenny Says So: The Post-Divorce Set-Up Parade

Dear Jenny,

Iโ€™m freshly divorced and still very much in the โ€œmy nervous system is doing construction workโ€ phase. Iโ€™m not sitting around sobbing all day, but I also donโ€™t feel shiny and ready to be someoneโ€™s plus-one at a wine bar. Butโ€” people are coming out of the woodwork to set me up.

A friend sent me a screenshot of this personโ€™s Instagram and said, โ€œTheyโ€™re perfect for you.โ€ My aunt told me, โ€œThe best way to get over someone is to get under someoneโ€ (I almost dropped my phone). Someone at a party asked if I was โ€œback out there yetโ€ like I was returning a library book. I know they mean well, but it makes me feel like my divorce is being treated like a vacancy sign.

Iโ€™m also embarrassed because I donโ€™t want to seem bitter or prudish. I just want space. I want to recalibrate. I want to learn who I am again before Iโ€™m asked to audition for a new relationship.

What do I do when someone tries to set me up immediately? How do I shut it down without hurting feelingsโ€”or getting sucked into a conversation I donโ€™t want?

Love,
Not Ready in Nottingham


Dear Not Ready,

First: youโ€™re allowed to heal at human speed. You are not a clearance rack. You are not a project. And you do not need to โ€œprove youโ€™re fineโ€ by dating quickly.

Hereโ€™s the etiquette truth: when someone offers a set-up, youโ€™re not rejecting themโ€”youโ€™re setting a boundary around your timeline. Kindness doesnโ€™t require compliance.

Use VASEโ€”Validate, Acknowledge, Support, Expressโ€”and keep it simple.

Validate: โ€œThatโ€™s really thoughtful.โ€
Acknowledge: โ€œI know youโ€™re trying to support me.โ€
Support: โ€œWhat helps most right now is friendship, not matchmaking.โ€
Express: โ€œIf that changes, Iโ€™ll tell you.โ€

Scripts you can steal:

  • โ€œThatโ€™s so kind. Iโ€™m not dating yetโ€”Iโ€™m focusing on stabilizing my life. But I really appreciate you thinking of me.โ€

  • โ€œIโ€™m taking a dating sabbatical. If/when Iโ€™m ready, I promise youโ€™ll be the first to know.โ€

  • โ€œRight now, the best support is inviting me to normal thingsโ€”not introducing me to new people.โ€

If they push: โ€œI hear you. And Iโ€™m still a no.โ€

Youโ€™re not behind. Youโ€™re just rebuilding.


Check out more Jenny Says So

Previous
Previous

Divorce 101: J Is for Joint Custody (and June)

Next
Next

Review: Unfuck Your Parenting by Bonnie Scott & Faith G. Harper