Jenny Says So: Blocking, Muting, and “Am I Petty?”

Dear Jenny,

I’m newly divorced and my social media feels like a booby trap.

I keep seeing my ex pop up in roundabout ways—mutual friends posting group photos, inside jokes, “so grateful for this crew” captions that happen to include my ex in the corner. Sometimes people tag them. Sometimes they tag me. Sometimes someone shares a memory and I’m not even in it, but I still feel like I got yanked backward by the collar.

I know social media isn’t real life, but my body doesn’t seem to know that. I’ll be having a totally okay day and then I see a post and it’s like my brain starts replaying everything. And then I’m mad at myself for caring. And then I’m mad that I’m mad.

So I started muting a few mutual friends. And now I’m considering blocking a couple people who keep “updating” my ex’s life online like it’s community theater and I’m supposed to applaud. But I feel guilty. Like I’m being childish. Like I’m proving I’m “not over it.” Like people will notice and talk.

Is it petty to block or mute mutuals on social media? What’s the etiquette here?

Love,

Unraveling in Upper West Side


Dear Unraveling,

Muting is not petty. It’s modern manners.

Here’s the etiquette rule: your feed is not a public utility. It’s your nervous system’s living room. And if something repeatedly spikes your stress, you are allowed to change the channel without writing a dissertation about why.

Muting is the most diplomatic option because it’s quiet and non-performative. It doesn’t “punish” anyone. It just gives you space to heal without getting jump-scared by other people’s posts.

Blocking is also not inherently petty—it’s a boundary tool. You block when someone is consistently disrespectful, invasive, or causing harm (including the low-grade harm of chronic retraumatization). You do not need to wait until you’re in a full crisis to protect yourself.

If you’re worried about optics, remember: healing is not a group project. People who interpret your boundaries as drama were always going to misread you.

If someone asks directly, here’s a simple script:

“I’m taking a social media break from anything divorce-adjacent. It’s nothing personal—I’m just protecting my peace.”

And if a mutual keeps posting “updates” that feel pointed?

“I’m keeping my online world really calm right now, so I’m stepping back.”

You’re not childish. You’re creating quieter inputs so you can build a steadier life.


Check out more Jenny Says So

Previous
Previous

I’m Divorced and a Divorce Professional—Here’s What I Learned

Next
Next

Hey Olivia, how can I use my pain for purpose?